“I Don’t Know” is a Real Answer

One thing that often crops up with Creationists talking about the Big Bang is the straw man that atheism requires a belief that “something came from nothing.” I’m not a cosmologist. I’m not an astrophysicist. I am merely an interested layman who tries to pay attention to what the scientists are speculating about the origin of the universe as we know it. Where did the universe come from? What caused the Big Bang? My honest answer is “I don’t know.”

Our understanding of the universe is incomplete. There are gaps we would love to fill, but don’t have the necessary evidence or understanding to fill them. Because I don’t know, I avoid recklessly filling them with false or untestable explanations. That’s something Creationists can’t seem to wrap their heads around.

Given the existing evidence, we can infer that the universe was once compacted into a singularity, and that includes time and space. Scientists have the gist of the universe’s history down to within some tiny fraction of a second after the inferred expansion started. The models we have right now break down if you try to work back any farther. We’ve got various hypotheses that are being entertained, but no one can honestly be confident in any of them because they haven’t been tested, yet. Some of these speculations haven’t been developed enough to conceive of a test. Until the test results come in, I have no reason to favor one over another, so I can simply say “I don’t know.” Because I don’t know of any evidence that favors any of those origin hypotheses, I lack a belief in any of them.

Here’s where things may get interesting: I think it’s possible that a god of some kind might have been involved, but I have no reason to think it’s probable. I don’t know of any evidence to support any god, so I lack belief in gods. Given the past failures of previous hypotheses about human-like supernatural beings, and the complexity they would add unnecessarily, I’d say they’re less probable than other origin hypotheses. That’s what makes me an agnostic atheist.

7 responses to ““I Don’t Know” is a Real Answer

  1. An answer I have given on a couple of occasions is along the following lines:

    “We don’t know… well, actually we don’t even know that much: We don’t even know what questions to ask to figure out what question to ask.”

  2. A friend of mine once told me that I was brave to be able to say “I don’t know” when asked about things. (We were discussing the definition of love, for the curious.) I can’t understand why that takes bravery; “I don’t know” is my default answer to anything. That’s how it should be; if you don’t know, you don’t know. Saying anything contrary to that generally does nothing good. (Unless it’s a multiple choice test with no penalty for incorrect answers, in which case… go for it?)

    …oh. Also. Hi. Been a while. ‘sup.

    • Hey. How’s life treating you? Been continuing my grad work.

      And yeah, it should be easy to say “I don’t know” when you don’t know. Religion only makes that a problem because it’s essentially pointing out the emperor’s lack of clothing.

      • Doing alrightish. Survived freshman year of college with an almost-but-not-quite B despite some now-mostly-gone depression clouding the entire second semester. Summer began with a car accident, which wasn’t good, but it was completely and utterly inconsequential for everyone and everything involved that /wasn’t/ a car, other than having to deal with assigning blame and who pays for it. (Seriously. I’ve been playing the crap out of a PS3 that was in the seemingly-demolished trunk of my car. None of my other stuff was damaged at /all/, same for everyone else.)

  3. Good post, I was led to your site from The Skeptic’s Dictionary and i’ve enjoyed going through the whole thing, archival and recent, keep it up mate.

    • You were in the ‘Skeptical Links’ section of the dictionary, can’t remember how I found my way from your older site to this newer one. Other skeptical sites have helped me find a link i’m after, like the true path to StopSylvia! PS: Gotta go, my boss is slithering this way!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s